Should Joe Biden have been denied Communion?


The recent report that a priest in the Diocese of Charleston, South Carolina, refused holy Communion to former Vice President Joe Biden brought to center stage, once again, the question of how the Church, in its discipline and pastoral practice, should react to political figures who identify themselves as Catholics but politically or legislatively enable abortion — a grave evil in the mind of the Church.

First, it is not just an American problem. It is worldwide. A Canadian reader of Our Sunday Visitor often wrote to me to lambaste political figures in his country who are friendly to abortion but list themselves as Catholics. In reply, I noted to him that of Canada’s nine prime ministers in the last half-century, five have referred to themselves as Roman Catholics, and each of these five, including the incumbent, have supported legal abortion.

Go below the top level of politicians. The number of Catholics who sit in our Congress or in parliaments abroad and declare themselves to be Catholics but are in favor of abortion on demand, frankly, is shocking.

Church law regarding abortion excommunicates the mother of the aborted child and anyone who assisted in the actual procedure. Many Canon lawyers say the restriction stops with a narrow reading of the statute. Others disagree.

Some years ago, Belgium’s King Baudouin, a very devout Catholic, now deceased, and uncle of the present Belgian king, looked at his official conduct regarding abortion. He did so with his faith first and foremost in his thinking. Belgium’s parliament, democratically elected in every sense by a population that overwhelmingly identified itself as Catholic and composed of mostly Catholic members, passed a bill legalizing abortion.

Under the Belgian constitution, no parliamentary act could become law without the monarch’s approval. No monarch had refused approval in over 130 years, but Baudouin said that, as a believing Catholic, he could not give his consent.

This was his reasoning. Realizing his authority under the constitution and knowing that the constitution allowed him to act as he saw fit, he would have to take at least some responsibility if abortion was legalized.

The politicians howled, but the king stood his ground. Finally, parliament declared him unfit to reign, for the moment, and the law took effect, but Baudouin never relented.

God bless the memory of this courageous and deeply Catholic modern king.

The same line of thought applies to other figures, anywhere in the world, who have a role in lawmaking. Obviously many opinions occur in societies. For a Catholic or for anyone who analyzes what abortion is, rights — indeed the most basic, the right to life — are denied to the human being most affected: the unborn child. Catholics can have no part of it.

The incident involving former Vice President Biden was defended as being within the expressed policy of the Diocese of Charleston, enacted in 2004. To be honest, not every diocese in the universal Church has such a policy, declared in such precise terms.

As a result, while many Catholics find the situation of these politicians utterly unacceptable, others cite the exact terms of Church law and say that such politicians, who regard themselves as Catholics but condone abortion on demand, are within the law.

Only the Roman pontiff can authoritatively interpret, change or amend Church law for all to obey. Many bishops think that they should take their cue from Rome. Since abortion came to be legal throughout the world, no recent pope in office — Pope St. Paul VI, Pope John Paul I, Pope St. John Paul II, Pope Benedict XVI or Pope Francis — has explicitly included in the law an item regarding holy Communion to political supporters of abortion.

In no democracy do politicians just seize power. Voters elect them. Individual citizens, specifically including Catholics, put politicians in office, so citizens are responsible.

Society needs to learn what abortion actually is and whom it ultimately affects.

This article comes to you from OSV Newsweekly (Our Sunday Visitor) courtesy of your parish or diocese.


Catholic News & Perspective

Provides information on the Church, the nation and the world from OSV, America's most popular and trusted national Catholic news source


Opening the Word: Hearing the Baptist’s cry

Friday, December 6, 2019
By: Timothy P. O'Malley It’s hard to appreciate the intensity of John the Baptist. His clothing is that of an ancient prophet like Elijah.... Read More

Channeling Mary’s generous heart this Christmas

Wednesday, December 4, 2019
By: Abby Johnson Gift-giving is my love language. Birthdays, holidays, anniversaries — it doesn’t matter. My friends and family are... Read More

A history lesson on the Vatican’s support of a two-state solution in the Holy Land

Monday, December 2, 2019
By: Msgr. Owen F. Campion It all began in 1948. Exhausted by the Second World War and tired of maintaining their worldwide empire, the British left... Read More

Opening the Word: Keeping vigilant for the coming of Jesus

Friday, November 29, 2019
By:  Timothy P. O'Malley Both political and economic theories presume that planning is a good. A business should have a surplus of funds,... Read More

Tensions crop up as bishops set the course for the future of the U.S. Church

Wednesday, November 27, 2019
By: Russell Shaw In an action with historic significance, the U.S. bishops at their fall general assembly for the first time ever chose a Hispanic... Read More

Beauty is the answer to the longing of the human heart

Monday, November 25, 2019
By: Kathryn Jean Lopez They had me at Santca Mariatzine. Although truth be told, that was the icing on the cake, so to speak, of the Mass of the... Read More

Opening the Word: Christ alone is King

Friday, November 22, 2019
By: Timothy P. O'Malley While the most recent Election Day is behind us, it’ll be no time at all before our televisions once again will be... Read More

Court cases prompt question: When is a child a child?

Wednesday, November 20, 2019
By: Lawrence P. Grayson Two court cases — one currently being considered, the other soon to be — raise numerous questions about when a... Read More

Celebrating the feast of Christ the King

Monday, November 18, 2019
By: Msgr. Owen F. Campion The feast of Christ the King is celebrated throughout the Catholic world this year on Sunday, Nov. 24. Easter and... Read More

Opening the Word: The Great Conflagration

Friday, November 15, 2019
By: Timothy P. O'Malley Over the last few years, we’ve looked closely at God’s mercy. In this column itself, it has been noted that in... Read More